Knitty: little purls of wisdom

For almost as long as I've been a knitter, I've been fascinated by the history of knitting. I've especially enjoyed the mind-twisting process of working with the often obtuse and obfuscatory language of antique patterns. There's a thrill, I find, in watching a project emerge row by row and knowing that other knitters, long gone, followed the same path.

The process of decoding, testing and correcting isn't for everyone, though; and so in this column I hope to share the excitement of the journey by removing as many of the roadblocks as possible. You don't need to be a historian to come along -- just a knitter with a curious mind.

When I started writing this column, interest in old patterns was still a highly specialized taste within the larger knitting community. People who got into a froth over the stockings of Eleanor of Toledo or the Gunnister purse were looked upon like the table at the foodie convention that orders fried spiders as an appetizer. They were, in a word, weirdos. Possibly respected weirdos, or even admired weirdos; but weirdos nonetheless.

Things have changed. As part of my teaching schedule I'm frequently called upon to present a class that introduces knitters of all kinds to nineteenth century patterns. It makes me fizzy with joy every time a host asks for that class, and even fizzier when the class sells out -- which it generally does.

Yet mere mention of the subject still sometimes brings knitting chatter to a halt.

"What are you making?" a fellow knitter asks.

"It's a [whatever], from a Victorian pattern."

"Wow. Well, better you than me."

"What? Why? No! You should try it. Old patterns are really fun."

"No," comes the inevitable reply, "I don't lead that kind of lifestyle."

Then they speed off in the direction of the exit or the open bar. Otherwise, I'd ask these folks what sort of lifestyle they think I lead. Do I travel to fiber festivals in a stage coach? Is my Internet connection powered by a water wheel? Does my smart phone have a Butter Churn app?

I have affinity for the aesthetics of the nineteenth century, sure. However, Tasha Tudor I am not. A fondness for cufflinks and detachable collars does not indicate a willingness on my part to be separated from my automatic washing machine.

This drives a certain other segment of the knitting population crazy. I get messages:

"I am writing to point out that your use of a modern sock yarn containing nylon to knit the [whatever] is historically inaccurate. I hope you are carried away bodily by a swarm of angry moths and never seen again."

Let it be understood that I wholeheartedly support the rigorous use of appropriate patterns, methods, and materials in historically sensitive situations.* But for regular daily usage, there's nothing sacred about a pattern just because it's hit the century-or-more mark. I've never knit a pattern without bending it to my will, regardless of who wrote it or when.

That's why this issue's project is (as it says right there in the name) a wholly irreverent mash-up two bits of knitting from the polar ends of the Victorian era.

First Bit: The Hat Part

This is early Victorian, and in fact from one of the earliest widely published books on knitting aimed at a hobbyist market: Jane Gaugain's The Lady's Assistant in Knitting, Netting, and Crochet (1840). We've used it before, most memorably for the Big D-mn Pineapple.

This time, the pattern is remarkable for its simplicity: a counterpane square that is more square-ish, decorated with nothing more than alternating bands of garter stitch and stockinette. By itself, it is nothing much. Multiplied as it was intended to be, it would make a handsome blanket.

There's the trouble, at least for me. I admire the living hell out of counterpanes, but I don't want to knit one. I have trouble knitting the same thing more than once. Pairs are fine. I like socks and mittens. But the same square sixty times or more?

I originally thought that I'd knit two (which, as you can see, I did) and sew them together to make the top of a little rectangular throw pillow, in the manner of the Star Pincushion.

As I sewed, I became less enthusiastic about that idea. Not because I didn't think it would look nice or work well; but I'd already done a pillow. I stitched and puzzled and stitched and puzzled and absentmindedly sewed not one but two edges together. And there it was: a little pointy hat.

Sometimes it happens that way. You don't know what you're making until you've made it.

Second Bit: The Fringe

It was a slightly prim hat, just plain, so why not make it fancy? It happened that there was something I'd been wanting to try out on this page for ages without knowing quite how to fit it in: a knitted fringe.

The published pattern for the fringe technique, from Weldon's Practical Mountmellick Embroidery, is late (or at least late-ish) Victorian, though the embroidery with which it was paired was developed in Ireland the 1820s and so pre-dates Victoria's accession.

Mountmellick embroidery used rather coarse white cotton thread to create motifs (mostly floral or botanical) on white cotton fabric in a wide variety of stitches. The knitted fringe (worked in four to eight strands of the embroidery cotton held together) trimmed the edges of work bags, hair tidies, tray and table cloths, and anything else the Mountmellick workers could stick a needle through.

Of course, fringe is not unusual in knitting. Usually, though, it's knotted. This fringe is knitted -- you make what looks like a curious strip of braid, bind off some of the stitches, and unravel the others. Presto! Fringe!

Stitched to the top of the hat, it creates a slightly punk rock effect that I think will lend much-needed street cred to any baby.

*I once wrote a letter of protest regarding an ugly pink acrylic baby blanket on display in the cradle of the day room at the Frank Lloyd Wright Home and Studio in Oak Park, Illinois -- a place where the docents mention every four minutes how perfectly accurate every tiny detail is. Word has reached me that the blanket is gone, replaced by something suitable. I have no idea whether this had anything to do with me, but at least now I can sleep at night.

pink needle

beauty shotblank

by Franklin Habit, adapted from patterns in The Lady's Assistant in Knitting, Netting, and Crochet (1840) by Jane Gaugain and Weldon's Practical Mountmellick Embroidery, First Series (1880s)


spacer photos: Franklin Habit  

Baby through Toddler (fits head circumference 14–16 inches)

Width: 8 inches across
8.5 inches high



Rauma Garn Pelini [50% Pima cotton/50% linen; 102m per 50g skein]
spacer [MC] 9475 (blue), 1 skein
spacer [CC] 10 (tan), 1 skein

Recommended needle size
[always use a needle size that gives you the gauge listed below -- every knitter's gauge is unique]
spacer 1 set US #2/2.75mm straight needles

spacer yarn needle
spacer stitch markers (2)
spacer scissors



26 sts/52 rows (26 ridges) = 4 inches in garter stitch

[Knitty's list of standard abbreviations and techniques can be found here.]

Slipped st selvedge. Every row starts with the first st slipped purlwise, with yarn in front.

M1. Inc 1 st using backward loop CO as described here.

Long Tail cast on. It is vital that the cast on for the fringe be uniform but loose, or working the first row will bring on a migraine. My suggestion is to cast on using the long tail method and intentionally put space between each stitch as you cast it onto the needle. Using a larger needle or two needles held together won't make the cast on any looser.

YO at beginning of row. Bring working yarn over tip of right needle from front to back; continue row as directed.

Mattress stitch. Instructions may be found here.

Whip stitch.
Instructions may be found here.

[Make 2: one each in MC and CC]

CO 2.

Row 1 [WS]: K2.

Row 2 [RS]: Sl 1, m1, k1. 3 sts.

Row 3 [WS]: Sl 1, k2.

Row 4 [RS]: Sl 1, m1, k2. 4 sts.

Row 5 [WS] Sl 1, k3.

Row 6 [RS]: Sl 1, k1, m1, k2. 5 sts.

Row 7 [WS]: Sl 1, k4.

Row 8 [RS]: Sl 1, k1, m1, k3. 6 sts.

Row 9 [WS]: Sl 1, k5.

Row 10 [RS]: Sl, k2, place marker, m1, place marker, k3. 7 sts; 1 st between markers.

Row 11 [WS]: Sl 1, k to end of row.

Work Stockinette Increase Stripe as follows:
Row 1 [RS]: Sl 1, k to second marker, m1, sl m, k3. 1 st increased.
Row 2 [WS]: Sl 1, k2, p to second marker, m1, sl m, k3. 1 st increased.
Repeat the last 2 rows once more.

Work Garter Stitch Increase Stripe as follows:
Row 1 [RS]: Sl 1, k to second marker, m1, sl m, k3. 1 st increased.
Row 2 [WS]: Sl 1, k to second marker, m1, sl m, k3. 1 st increased.
Repeat the last 2 rows twice more.

Continue, alternating Stockinette and Garter Stitch Increase Stripes until you have 53 sts on ndl (47 sts between markers). You will have finished the first ridge (first two rows) of a garter stitch stripe.

Start Decreases as follows:
Row 1 [RS]: Sl 1, k to 2 sts before second marker, k2tog, k3. 1 st decreased.
Row 2 [WS]: Sl 1, k to 2 sts before second marker, k2tog, k3. 1 st decreased.
Repeat the last 2 rows once more. 43 sts between the markers.

Work Stockinette Decrease Stripe as follows:
Row 1 [RS]: Sl 1, k to 2 sts before second marker, k2tog, k3. 1 st decreased.
Row 2 [WS]: Sl 1, k2, p to 2 sts before second marker, p2tog, k3. 1 st decreased.
Repeat the last 2 rows once more.

Work Garter Stitch Decrease Stripe as follows:
Row 1 [RS]: Sl 1, k to 2 sts before second marker, k2tog, k3. 1 st decreased.
Row 2 [WS]: Sl 1, to 2 sts before second marker, k2tog, k3. 1 st decreased.
Repeat the last 2 rows twice more.

Continue, alternating Stockinette and Garter Stitch Decrease Stripes until you have 9 sts on ndl (3 sts between markers).

When 9 sts remain (you will have finished a garter stripe), work end of piece as follows.

Final rows:
Row 1 [RS]: Removing markers as you come to them, Sl 1, k3, k2tog, k3. 8 sts.

Row 2
[WS]: Sl 1, knit to end.

Row 3
[RS]: Sl 1, k2, k2tog, k3. 7 sts.

Row 4
[WS]: Sl 1, knit to end.

Row 5
[RS]: Sl 1, k2, k2tog, k2. 6 sts.

Row 6
[WS]: Sl 1, knit to end.

Row 7
[RS]: Sl 1, k1, k2tog, k2. 5 sts.

Row 8
[WS]: Sl 1, knit to end.

Row 9
[RS]: Sl 1, k2tog, k2. 4 sts.

Row 10
[WS]: Sl 1, knit to end.

Row 11
[RS]: Sl 1, k2tog, k1. 3 sts.

Row 12
[WS]: Sl 1, knit to end.

Row 13
[RS]: Sl 1, k2tog. 2 sts.


With both yarns held together, use long tail method (see Pattern Notes) to CO 6 sts over two needles held together.

Row 1: (YO, k2tog, k1) across.

Repeat Row 1 for desired length.

BO 3 sts. Break working yarns and draw through last st on right ndl. Sl rem sts off left ndl and unravel them to form looped fringe.

Weave in ends of both halves and gently block. Allow to dry completely.

Weave in ends of knitted fringe.

Arrange the two halves with WS together and BO points at top. Using a length of either color, use mattress stitch to sew the pieces together along top two sides.

Pin fringe along seam line at top of hat, taking care to align center with top point. With a length of either color, use whip stitch to sew fringe securely to hat. (Stitches are easily made through the eyelets in the selvedge of the fringe.)

Put hat on baby. Accept compliments with as much humility as you can muster.

Franklin Habit lives in Chicago, Illinois but spends much of his time teaching elsewhere. He is the proprietor of the popular blog The Panopticon and his work appears regularly in major needlework publications.

For somebody with no children, he sure spends a lot of time knitting little clothes.