Wednesday, May 02, 2007

Gloves off.

Who the gloves were on for, that I don't know. Me, maybe. But it's time and I'm just going to say it.

I'm really, really tired of my body ruining my knitting fun.

If you've read my blog for a while, you know my body size doesn't stay the same size for more than 2 seconds in a row. Wonder why I knit so many lacy shawls? It's because they always fit.

I've been big and little [relatively speaking] over and over again my whole life. Even when I'm in a reasonably stable body-size period, no measurement stays the same for more than a month or so. I've come to accept this. I've panicked-dieted from real big to what I consider the perfect size [for me...which is about a 14] more than once in my life. But I can only sustain that panicked state for so long. Operating based on underlying panic doesn't make me happy. It does nothing but keep me in mental freak-out overdrive and fool me into throwing out larger pairs of jeans that I'm likely going to need when the panic subsides.

Aside: This is not a rant about dieting and how I'm going to embrace it again and dammit, this time it will stick! I am D.O.N.E. with dieting, and that includes the most-sensible diet of all, Weight Watchers. I can only stay on the program when I'm in panic mode. How could that possibly be a healthy way to live my life?

This rant is the result of another sweater. I cast on for a really cute super-deep-u-necked fitted vest last night in the hand-dyed deep aqua cotton I bought at the Knitter's Frolic. And then I ripped it out before I finished the first row, because I can feel that my body wants to be a little smaller. I've pretty much been the queen of the slugs all winter, meeting writing deadlines, and now it's time to get out of the house and off my ass.

But what size will I be? Do I have to wait till I get to wherever that is to knit my damned aqua fitted vest? If I knit it now and it's too big by a few inches, it won't be a fitted sexy vest.

I am very aware of -- and believe in -- the BGK philosophy: knit for your body NOW, as it is, no blinders on. But I'm also very aware of how frustrating that can be if you're like me and your body doesn't stay the same size long enough for a sweater to fit you by the time you're done [too big, too small, what's the diff?].

Jillian and I have talked about this and we have no answer except to knit a wrap. I don't want a wrap. I want that damned aqua fitted vest.

A friend has recently gotten noticeably smaller [several inches in the chest, at least], right in the middle of a knitting project. What did she do when it turned out to be too big? She frogged it and has started over. She's a braver woman than I.

Instead, I'm knitting on my deep pink Cables & Os, which will look good and be forgiving of any up-or-downsizing of this body of mine. But the hand-dyed aqua cotton is in a basket, staring at me. I think it's pretty cruel that what I do for relaxation and enjoyment has to be so strongly tied to the size of my body.

Scrapbookers don't have this problem, do they?

---

eta: I knew there were more of us with this concern than just me. You want to see the yarn?



and because I know you'll ask:


As is my way, after the moaning and complaining, I've decided to just knit the thing. I will use good BGK principles and add in some design details that may [I hope] act as built-in body-forgiving devices. Jillian's helping me by writing up my pattern. It's not Morrigan, after all. It's not a year-long commitment. It's a vest.

Regarding my original post, I still don't know what the answer is. Maybe I'll invent some kind of cutesy way to take in sweaters with ribbons or pleating or something if I get noticeably smaller. Clever use of shawl pins? If I get bigger, well, knitting stretches. But I'd really like not to get bigger.

Labels: ,

Comments:
This is why I have a closet full of shoes and bags! They always fit.
 
Yes, but scrapbookers have to carry lots of heavy stuff to their scrap-ins. We sit in the comfy chairs at my LYS and laugh at them as they truck things on on their dollys. (Not kidding there!)

I'm with you on the body size issues though. It's ugh.
 
Just think though, when scrapbookers cut that paper or stamp that stamp, that sucker has been cut and stamped and there's no going back! Yarn lets you have the luxury to rip back and start over as much as you need.
 
You just TOTALLY hit the nail on the head for me. I am relatively new to knitting, but feel ready for the sweater challnge, only how on earth can I make a sweater when I have no idea what size I will be when it is done??? I want to make something nice for myself, something where after I spend a LOT of money on yarn, and put a LOT of my time and energy into it, I can wear it and look great. Honestly, I was feeling a bit lonely in that particular train of thought....at least now I know it is not just me :-)
 
This same issue has kept me from knitting alot of things I would love to.
 
And sticky glue-hands...and paper cuts...and unwieldy tools...

We, on the other hand, have sticks and string...string that may at one time have been goop. Think about it...using goop and sticks, we have beautiful flowing seasilk fabric.

What about something knit on the bias?
 
Ahhhhhh, this is why I love your BGK book....it gives you the designs that are pretty good one size bigger or one size smaller. But I do totally understand too...all that effort for a sweater and then when it's done, it don't fit. But it's the same for me with "regular" clothes too..have a range of sizes in my closet.
 
I lurve you dearly.
 
I think this is why I'm sort of glad that my weight loss and gain are in the tummy region...which tends to be smaller (at least a bit!) than the chestal region. That way at least I know what bust size to make!

Let's get out and shed that winter padding!
 
I feel your pain, doll. In the 4 years I have been knitting, I have gone up about 4 dress sizes, and I don't even know how many bra sizes. In my mind, I am my previous smaller size, and hope to be again in reality someday. This creates knitting struggles--there are so many sweaters I want to make for myself, but I refuse to start any of them for fear that they eventually won't fit. My solution: sock knitting!
 
Dude. As I read this I'm frogging almost half a back of my Jane Origami sweater which I'd started knitting in the larger size because I'd tried on the store sample which was a small and just didn't want my boobs calling that much attention to themselves. 3 friggin weeks later (after some drinking at Megan's birthday night. ahem) I tried the sample on again because the knitted piece in my hands was beginning to scare me lengthwise. I kid you not it fit better. And with the walking I'm doing more of now the weather doesn't suck, that'll probably continue.

Unlike Laura though, my chest size is a pretty good indicator of weight gain/loss. Which BITES.
 
i have yet to start a sweater for this very reason. i was going to ask you for advice the next time we met. :)
 
Oh, baybee. Being the owner of so many big, square sweaters (cuz I knew they'd fit - look like crap - but fit) I hear ya.

But might I boldly suggest something you already know to be true? Why not mod your vest to add side panels, something along the lines of Curvalicious? I'm thinking more like princess seaming rather than something as dramatically angular as Curvi, but you get the notion. That way *if* things change, you'd only have to amend the sides?
 
I just had a new baby a couple of months ago and also started a sweater. Perhaps delusional. However, I decided to make some of the Fleece Artist/Handmaiden kits knit sideways... they wrap a bit in the front and are closed with shawl pins. (The Celtic Vest, Maid Marian vest, Imogen, Lady of the Lake sweater...) these seem to me to be good solutions to the 'what size will it fit' dilemma. I hope. :-) Maybe a technique like that for your vest? Just a thought.
 
My comment is a bit different from the ones previously posted, in that I'm not suggesting what kind of sweater or vest to make, but rather am suggesting a technique I use myself (but for a different purpose). I'm a grad student and really shouldn't be reading knit blogs or even knitting, but rather I should be working on my dissertation. The strategy that I've developed is to use knitting and reading knit blogs as a reward. I develop little reward challenges, like if I write a page of something I'm working on for school, I can read two blog entries or I can work on knitting a sock. My suggestion: create reward challenges for yourself that involve exercise as the activity that you get rewarded for and knitting time as the reward. If you're motivated and dedicated enough, this just might work. If you also go about by setting target measurements (or weight) to achieve you could plan on making a sweater or vest that corresponds to your target measurement, making your knitting that much more rewarding in the end. Good luck!
 
Mm.. my time and desire for exercise and activity fluctuates through the year, and I try to avoid reward-based mentality, 'cause that flips over to punishment... so Anonymous' suggestion wouldn't work for ME! I much like the grand acceptance of whatever size my body feels like being.. though my swings are on a two or three-year cycle, rather than the frequency of yours, poor thing!

I liked the suggestion of making changeable side panels - in my head, fun alterations would include eyelets for lacing things tighter or looser as needed, but I'm betting that wouldn't suit the style of your fitted vest - any opportunities to substitute some 1x1 rib in strategic places, to be blocked out as needed? Good luck!
 
Amen, sister! Congrats for being brave enough to tell it like it is. I've just come to the exact same conclusion - I'm totally tired of knitting the wool of three sheep just to make a sweater that will fit. Am currently knitting a tunic in the Textured Knits book - and losing weight. Said tunic will likely be too big by the time I finish - but I DON'T CARE! Enough is enough and I'm tired of being too big!!!
 
I'm having the same issue right now thanks to nursing. My chest measurement changes depending on how recently Thumper's eaten, and I have no friggin idea of what that measurement will be when he eventually weans. Combine that with my changed shape post-baby that still seems to be in flux and choosing a size to cast on is a matter of guessing and hoping for luck.
 
Oh, man, I hear you. My problem is actually that I'm clinging to the idea of not losing weight...because then my sweaters wouldn't fit!

That is a terrible reason for being unhealthy no matter how pretty my new Rogue is.

You are not alone. Thanks for posting this - it's nice to know I'm not the only one who gets frustrated by this.
 
You know what? Maybe it's just my novice knitter perspective, but I don't think it all has to do with the size of your body. Ready to wear clothing sizes vary immensely, right? (Not all larges, or 14's or 42's are created equal despite the fact that some of them refer to actual inch measurements.) Is that not sometimes true of knitting patterns? Especially with all the variables with quage. Even if one never gained or lost an ounce of weight there is no guarantee your finished knit is going to fit. No matter what size you are, fit is always an issue!
 
...and I spelled "gauge" wrong again - what is with me and that word! (sorry to clog up your comments with my spelling issues, but for god's sake, I even put a "Q" in it this time!)
 
Cardigans. Wear them open, wear them shut. Works for me every time. ;-)
 
quage! i love it!
 
Oh man. You are apparently my sister in weight fluctuation. I've never worried much about my size, because even at my "bigger" points, it's not really anything to complain about. But even when I keep my eating habits, exercise habits, EVERYTHING exactly the same, over the course of a year I will fluctuate between a size nine and a size fifteen. WTF. I've been wanting to make the Hot Tamale skirt for almost a year now, but my hips won't stay the same size for long enough!
 
This is why I don't knit pants, my size changes the most across my butt & every set of handknit pants I've ever seen got a saggy but after being worn. Knit for now if it doesn't fit when it's done it will still be in style, the loose stuff is popular right now.
 
Hey Amy, I realize this is not the point you're getting at, but have a look at this little pattern booklet:
http://berroco.com/255.262/262/262_photoview_pv.html
I ordered it from elann and I think 3 of the 4 designs are great weight-fluctuation projects, and they come in a good size range. And they're pretty. :)
xox
 
I am sooooo with you.

Granted, I'm not a sweater person so I'm not sure if I'll ever make one for myself regardless of my size... but for regular clothes I completely get it.

I'm going on 2 months now of eating decently. I'm really really hoping that it'll stick this time. I'm on new meds which is making most of the difficult things in my life a little bit easier and I'm sure that's a huge part of it. (not weight-related meds, but my food issues are related to my overall issues that the meds help with)

Anyway! Just wanted to express my support for all of us gals with weight issues!
 
I came over here to post the same thing as Cari. I'm dying to make myself a sweater, but I'm not really sure how my measurements might change as I continue nursing. I'm amazingly 10 lbs below my pre-pregnancy weight and I don't know whether the weight loss will continue.

Although I am thinking that I would like a wrap sweater...so that's what the hand-dyed wool-silk that I've been hoarding for two years might finally become...
 
The weight fluctuation thing is why I think I love midieval style drawstrings. You can make the sweater to fit the bigger you, but with X'd drawstrings across the back or sides, or under the bust, you can draw 'em in to accentuate the smaller you when you need to.
 
Do you think you could post the pattern for that fitted vest? It sounds like exactly what I am trying to knit, but I am too afraid to design my own ... am I a big wimp? Thanks!
 
Post a Comment